Top resume writing services comparison thread - post your experiences!

@Mandien Used Resume Writing Lab last semester. My experience:

Their "Professional" package
$145 (had a 10% student discount)
5 business days, but got it in 4
Quality was excellent - completely transformed how I presented my projects
YES - went from 0 callbacks to 3 interviews within two weeks

What surprised me most about these top professional resume writing services was how they translated my academic achievements into business value. They emphasized results over process, which apparently recruiters love.

Would 100% recommend. Worth every penny for engineering students who don't naturally think in marketing/business terms.

@Mandien i can share my experience with CraftResumes:

their entry-level package
$120-ish
standard 7 days
honestly better than expected - very professional formatting and wording
definitely got more interviews but cant say if it was JUST the resume

the cool thing about top resume writing service like CraftResumes is they know all the industry keywords to include. they assigned me a writer who specifically had experience with marketing resumes so they knew exactly what companies in my field look for.

if anyone wants to see a before/after, DM me!

My ranking of the top resume writing services I've tried (yes, I've job hunted A LOT 😅):

Resume Writing Lab - Best overall quality and industry knowledge
CraftResumes - Great value for money, solid results
[Some random local service] - Overpriced and generic

The biggest difference with the top rated resume writing services vs cheaper alternatives is they actually take time to understand your career goals rather than just reformatting what you give them.

@Mandien for your project, you might want to highlight that Resume Writing Lab offers specialized writers for different fields - that was the game-changer for me.

used both resume writing lab and a cheaper option from fiverr:

RWL's premium package vs $35 fiverr gig
$180 vs $35
5 days vs 2 days
night and day difference in quality
the cheap one got zero responses, RWL version got interviews

i think with these top professional resume writing services you really get what you pay for. the cheap one basically just reformatted my existing content, while Resume Writing Lab completely transformed how my experience was presented.

for context im in computer science and RWL writer had actual tech recruiting background

@Mandien for ur project, here's my experience with CraftResumes:

basic package
$125
5 days (said 7 but came early)
SO MUCH BETTER than what i had before
got internship at [major tech company] using it!!!

IMO the professional resume service was worth it because:

my DIY attempts were getting zero responses
they know how to handle the applicant tracking systems
the confidence boost alone helped in interviews

honestly think everyone should use these top resume writing services at least once to see how professionals market their experience

I've tried three different services:

Resume Writing Lab - $165
CraftResumes - $130
[Local career coach] - $250

The top resume writing services reviews don't lie - Resume Writing Lab was definitely the best investment. They completely transformed my boring academic projects into compelling professional experiences. Their writer asked really insightful questions about my work that helped uncover accomplishments I hadn't even thought to include.

CraftResumes was good too, but slightly less customized feeling. Still way better than trying to DIY though!

@Mandien happy to share the actual resumes for your project if that helps (with personal info redacted obviously)

Adding my experience to help with your comparison of top resume writing services:
Used Resume Writing Lab's rush service:

Premium package
$189 + $40 rush fee
48 hours (!!!)
Fantastic quality - they understand design industry
Got interviews at 4 out of 6 places I applied

What separated them from other top rated resume writing services I researched was their specialized knowledge of my field. The writer knew exactly which UX skills to emphasize and even suggested adding a QR code linking to my portfolio.

@Mandien make sure to mention in your project that having field-specific writers is a huge differentiator!

yo @Mandien my stats for CraftResumes:

their mid-tier resume package
$145 with student discount
standard 7 days
solid 9/10 quality
def helped - was job hunting for months before, got offer 3 weeks after

these top resume writing service pros know exactly how to position your experience. i had the same internships and projects on my old resume but somehow they made everything sound 10x more impressive without lying

https://craftresumes.com saved my job search fr

@Mandien Here's my breakdown of Resume Writing Lab since others have covered CraftResumes pretty well:

Their "Executive" package (wanted the LinkedIn optimization)
$195 total
Standard 5-day turnaround
Exceptional quality - complete transformation
Results: 5 applications → 3 interviews → 2 offers

What I appreciated about them compared to other top professional resume writing services was the consultation call. The writer spent 30 minutes really understanding my goals and strengths before drafting anything.

For your project, I'd highlight that the best services do more than just write - they help you identify and articulate your unique value proposition to employers.

just adding another data point for your top resume writing services comparison:
Resume Writing Lab:

Rush service
$175 (including rush fee)
48 hours
quality was amazing - completely transformed my engineering projects section
got an internship offer at the career fair!!!

what impressed me most was how they translated my technical projects into business benefits. like instead of just listing the tech i used, they focused on problems solved and efficiency gained.

definitely include in your research that these top rated resume writing services are especially helpful for STEM students who don't naturally think in marketing terms!

@Mandien I've used several professional resume service options since I've changed majors twice:

CraftResumes for my business admin resume - $135
Resume Writing Lab for my computer science resume - $165
[Campus career center] - Free

Honestly both paid services were excellent, but Resume Writing Lab had slightly better industry-specific knowledge for tech. Their writer had actually worked as a tech recruiter and knew exactly what skills to emphasize.

The free campus service was... well, you get what you pay for. Generic advice and templates that look like everyone else's resume.

For your comparison of top resume writing services, I'd emphasize that the industry expertise of the writer is arguably the most important factor.

My two cents for your top resume writing services reviews research:
CraftResumes:

Premium package
$175
7 days
Very professional, modern formatting
Definitely increased my callback rate

What I liked most about them vs other top professional resume writing services I researched was their guarantee - if you don't get more interviews within 30 days, they'll revise it for free.

@Mandien if you're including recommendations in your project, suggest to people that they request a writer with specific experience in their target industry. Makes a huge difference!